You do not need to perform a professional valuation yourself, but an initial classification makes a mixed collection easier to understand.
A practical first pass might create four groups:
Metal-ledBroken gold chains, simple bands, unmatched ordinary pieces
What are the metal, purity, and weight?
Fine jewelryDiamond rings, gemstone jewelry, platinum pieces
What are the stones and construction worth?
Designer / signedCartier, Tiffany & Co., Van Cleef & Arpels, Bulgari, Graff, other makers
Does brand and model create secondary-market value?
Estate / collectibleAntique, period, unusual, documented or finely made pieces
Is there value from maker, era, rarity, provenance, or design?
This is not a final valuation.
It is a way to prevent the fourth group from accidentally being sold using the methodology appropriate for the first.
Luxe Brokers' existing
estate jewelry process similarly separates pieces with maker, provenance, gemstones, rarity, era or collector demand from items driven mainly by material value.
For pieces whose value may be driven largely by precious-metal content, see
how gold jewelry is valued before treating the item as scrap.